Brooke has finally decided to tell Aiden her true feelings but two visitors from back East have her thinking about if that is the right decision. She planned to spend some time apart to decide but instead Brooke and Aiden get an interesting request, discover who is trying to kill a local Elf.
Gideon has had two attempts on his life and his pregnant wife, Bubbles, is urging him to ask for help but after meeting with Aiden and Brooke, Gideon is shot in the middle of the night with plenty of suspects because of his illicit lifestyle. With a fatherless baby on the way, Brooke decides to set aside her qualms and help Aiden find the killer.